Data & Decisions · Worksheet

The Heilmeier Catechism

The Heilmeier Catechism is a list of eight questions that DARPA, the research agency of the United States Department of Defense, asks about every proposed research program before the agency funds the program. George Heilmeier wrote the questions and ran DARPA from 1975 to 1977. The same eight questions work on any business proposal, from a new claims process to a software purchase. This page shows a weak and a strong answer to each question for one made-up proposal. At the end you answer the eight questions for your own proposal and print one page to take to the meeting.

Guess first

Where does this pitch fail?

A claims manager at a car insurer opens a funding request for $180,000 with this sentence:

“We will use AI to transform the claims experience with a digital-first platform.”

Tap an answer

Which of DARPA’s eight questions does the opening sentence fail first?